Clinton Global Initiative + The GRAMMY Foundation:: Designing a New Music Economy for New Orleans
New Orleans is one of the world's great cultural capitals.
Its music has shaped jazz, blues, funk, rhythm and blues, rock and countless other genres that continue to influence artists around the globe. The city's cultural identity is inseparable from its musicians.
Yet many of the people responsible for creating that culture struggle to earn a sustainable living from it.
This paradox sits at the heart of the creative economy.
Society celebrates artists. Cities market themselves through culture. Festivals, venues, tourism organizations and businesses derive enormous value from creative communities. Yet the musicians themselves often operate within economic systems that fail to recognize the realities of their work.
Traditional employment models assume predictable schedules, stable employers and conventional career paths.
Professional musicians live differently.
They work multiple gigs, navigate irregular income streams, rely on informal networks and often lack access to many of the protections and benefits available to traditional workers.
Recognizing this challenge, GREEN::HOUSE joined the Clinton Global Initiative and made a formal commitment to improve economic conditions for professional musicians in New Orleans in partnership with The GRAMMY Foundation and the New Orleans Jazz & Heritage Festival.
The commitment was ambitious::
"We commit to take action to improve the standard of living and bolster the social safety net for musicians working in New Orleans. Through this commitment, we will develop new, more effective models for directing financial resources and providing social services to musicians."
To tackle the challenge, GREEN::HOUSE convened an interdisciplinary team through our UX for Good initiative, bringing together leading user experience designers, strategists and researchers to explore the economic realities facing musicians throughout the city.
Rather than beginning with assumptions, the team immersed itself in the lives of working artists, seeking to understand how musicians actually navigate income, healthcare, career development and financial uncertainty.
The research revealed a fundamental problem:
Most support systems were designed for people with conventional careers.
Musicians were being asked to fit into systems that were never designed for them.
The solution was not to make musicians behave more like traditional workers.
The solution was to redesign systems around the realities of creative work.
The project generated a series of concepts and recommendations spanning financial services, social support systems, artist development and technology-enabled income generation.
Among the most influential findings was the need to rethink tipping itself. Long before digital tipping became commonplace, the team explored mechanisms that would allow audiences to support artists more directly and consistently. Several of the ideas generated through the project would later influence companies and platforms that enable musicians to automate and collect tips through digital channels.
Additional concepts explored new approaches to career management, resource coordination and support services tailored specifically to the needs of working artists.
As the final report concluded:
"To maintain the culture of music, musicians need access to different resource sets than other participants in the economy and social safety net. If we want musicians to keep doing the things musicians do, we need to design solutions that are compatible with the way musicians must live."
The project ultimately challenged a larger assumption about creative economies.
Culture is not self-sustaining.
If communities value artists, they must intentionally design systems that enable artists to thrive.
The work became one of the defining engagements within GREEN::HOUSE's UX for Good partnership, earning the user experience design industry's highest honor and helping establish a new framework for applying human-centered design to complex social challenges.
For GREEN::HOUSE, the project reinforced a lesson that remains highly relevant today::
The strongest economies are not built solely around industries.
They are built around people.
And when systems are designed around the realities of human lives, creativity becomes more than cultural expression.
It becomes a sustainable way of life. ::
The solution was not to make musicians behave more like traditional workers.
The solution was to redesign systems around the realities of creative work.
For related reading, see our work with The GRAMMYs, The Creative Coalition, The Museum of Contemporary Photography, and The West Collection.
"To maintain the culture of music, musicians need access to different resource sets than other participants in the economy and social safety net. If we want musicians to keep doing the things musicians do, we need to design solutions that are compatible with the way musicians must live."